Critical Race Theory: Behind Gov. Youngkin’s order banning ‘inherently divisive concepts’

RICHMOND, Va. (WAVY) — With the swipe of a pen, Gov. Glenn Youngkin fulfilled a campaign promise to lift educational requirements within the Commonwealth by first ending the usage of “inherently divisive ideas,” together with Important Race Principle, in Virginia’s public colleges.

The move came on Jan. 15 when Youngkin issued his first official memo: Govt Order 1. The signing of Govt Order 1 proposed various modifications to the Commonwealth’s public training system, together with a evaluation of the Virginia Division of Schooling’s insurance policies and curriculum.

However its important focus: Figuring out and eliminating what the governor’s workplace considers “divisive” or “inherently racist ideas.”

“Inherently divisive ideas, like Important Race Principle, and its progeny, instruct college students to solely view life via the lens of race and presumes that some college students are consciously or unconsciously racist, sexist, or oppressive, and that different college students are victims,” Youngkin wrote in Govt Order 1. “This denies our college students the chance to realize vital info, core data, formulate their very own opinions, and to suppose for themselves. Our kids deserve much better from their training than to be advised what to suppose.”

10 On Your Aspect investigators interviewed Youngkin about Govt Order 1. He stated his aim is to make sure Virginia’s educators aren’t instructing college students to evaluate each other.

“Our govt order that I signed was targeted on divisive ideas and simply to be sure that they’re not being included into colleges,” Youngkin stated. “These should not issues that individuals disagree over. We must always not train our youngsters that they need to be judged both to be an oppressor or to be a sufferer based mostly on their race, faith, or their intercourse.”

10 On Your Aspect investigators wished extra data on the implementation of Govt Order 1, so we submitted a Freedom of Data Act request for copies of written directives, directions, and steering from the governor’s workplace to VDOE. The governor’s workplace declined to meet our FOIA request, citing a bit of the regulation that makes “working papers and correspondence of the Workplace of the Governor” exempt from necessary launch.

10 On Your Aspect investigators requested Youngkin if he’s communicated with VDOE about Govt Order 1, and he stated sure.

“The brief reply is sure. The lengthy reply is we introduced in a bunch of recent individuals, and I’m excited concerning the individuals we introduced in,” Youngkin stated. “We had a unprecedented influx of expertise, and this expertise has been put to work immediately.”

Within the final 12 months, training consultants have usually stated that Important Race Principle isn’t taught in Virginia’s Ok-12 public colleges. 10 On Your Aspect investigators interviewed Atif Qarni, the previous secretary of training throughout Gov. Ralph Northam’s administration, and requested him if he’s conscious of Important Race Principle being a part of VDOE’s curriculum.

“No, CRT just isn’t taught wherever in our curriculum and requirements,” Qarni stated. “It’s to not my data. I do know that for a truth as a result of I reviewed each single curriculum and commonplace in my job. That was my job to evaluation that, and it’s not taught wherever.”

10 On Your Aspect investigators additionally spoke with Vivian Hamilton, a regulation professor and the director of William & Mary’s Heart for Social Justice who teaches Important Race Principle on the school degree. She stated Important Race Principle is a sophisticated mental motion that the majority regulation college students don’t find out about except they take specialised programs.

“It’s a physique of ideas that goals to grasp why Black individuals and different individuals of shade proceed to occupy the bottom-most social rungs of society,” Hamilton stated.

Important Race Principle has grow to be a hot-button challenge in American politics — from the race for the governor’s office, to local school board meetings. Hamilton stated she believes the political backlash in opposition to Important Race Principle stems from nationwide conversations about race that started in 2020 when George Floyd was murdered by a former Minneapolis police officer named Derek Chauvin.

“It generated resentment amongst quite a lot of white people who find themselves merely unaccustomed to desirous about race in a sustained means,” Hamilton stated.

Hamilton stated that Important Race Principle isn’t meant to make anybody really feel responsible, however seeks to coach individuals on the discrimination sure teams face in America. She agrees that Important Race Principle shouldn’t be taught in Virginia’s Ok-12 colleges, however believes that the aim of motions to ban it search to regulate the narrative of the Commonwealth’s sophisticated historical past.

“Studying just isn’t all the time snug and sure, classes should be age-appropriate and grade-appropriate,” she stated.

Youngkin stated the aim of Govt Order 1 isn’t to erase historical past however to make sure the great and dangerous are taught with out forcing youngsters to evaluate each other or telling them what they need to suppose.

“I feel it is a very clear message: Let’s not have divisive ideas that pressure our youngsters to evaluate each other via a lens of race, faith, or intercourse,” Youngkin stated. “Let’s train all of our historical past — the great and the dangerous.”