TV Rewind: An Ode to Banshee and Its Resilient, Complex Women

Editor’s Notice: Welcome to our TV Rewind column! The Paste writers are diving into the streaming catalogue to debate a few of our favourite traditional collection in addition to nice reveals we’re looking ahead to the primary time. Come relive your TV previous with us, or uncover what ought to be your subsequent binge watch under:

(Editor’s Notice: Remember there are some collection spoilers for Banshee under.)

The profitable rebranding of Cinemax within the 2010s rested on producing scripted originals that may entice the premium community’s majority male viewership. So it’s hardly a shock that the fan-favorite Banshee is seemingly tailored for the protoypical male gaze: extreme, grotesque violence is used as steadily as gratuitious intercourse and nudity are deployed inside its pulpy narrative, which follows an ex-con (Antony Starr) who walks the road between legal and cop after assuming the id of a not too long ago deceased sheriff. However spend a number of hours within the small hamlet of the collection’ title and a fact begins to emerge: There’s way more occurring than simply violence and intercourse, each by way of the overarching narrative and its many gamers. For those who stick round longer than that, you’ll additionally see that whereas Lucas Hood (Starr) may be an interesting (anti)hero who flirts with masculine fantasy—a number of stunning ladies fall into his mattress with laughable ease early on, together with the widow of a person he kills—the present truly belongs to the ladies in his life.

Excluding youngsters and the aged, the feminine characters of Banshee aren’t weak. They’re not often in want of saving, not from the alternatives they make nor the violence at their doorsteps. The writers subvert the damsel-in-distress trope early and sometimes, taking part in off viewers’ information of what the present’s many ladies, together with Carrie Hopewell (Ivana Milicevic), Siobhan Kelly (Trieste Kelly Dunn), and Nola Longshadow (Odette Annable), are able to, in addition to the expectations of these throughout the narrative who haven’t a clue. The result’s a thrilling takedown of male arrogance and misogyny as they harness their power and reveal why it’s a mistake to underestimate them. Their bodily talents are both equal to or surpass these of their usually male opponents, and so a number of the present’s most memorable motion scenes contain not Hood however these ladies, from Carrie’s practically episode-long brawl with Olek (Christos Vasilopoulos) in Season 1 to Nola’s made-to-look-like-a-single-take fight with Burton (Matthew Rauch) in Season 3.

However like Banshee itself, the strengths of its ladies exist past the bodily. They’re additionally extra emotionally advanced and mentally harder than the boys depicted within the present, principally as a result of they’ve needed to be on account of the hyper-masculine world through which they exist. Carrie is a chief instance of this. Her relationship with Hood is the muse upon which every part rests, and it’s dictated virtually totally by her needs and wishes. When Hood arrives in Banshee after serving a 15-year jail sentence, Carrie is without delay the girl he liked and not the girl he knew; on the run from her gangster father (Ben Cross) after double-crossing him years in the past, she left behind her life as Anastasia to grow to be the spouse of Gordon (Rus Blackwell) and mom of Deva (Ryann Shane) and Max (Gabriel Suttle). Her id was formed effectively earlier than we joined the story, and since she had a 15-year head begin on Hood, Carrie can also be the stronger, higher adjusted of the 2. She recognizes she can’t go back, that the connection and life they’d dreamed about in secret is lifeless. She didn’t must see the house Hood purchased for her go up in literal flames in one of many collection’ finest episodes (Season 2’s “The Fact About Unicorns”) to know that.

Hood is sluggish to achieve the identical conclusion; all through Season 1, he tries to make Carrie see that they belong collectively, even going as far as to make use of Deva—the daughter he by no means knew he had however acknowledged virtually immediately—as proof of their future relatively than a product of their shared previous. That Hood is the individual holding onto the final remaining traces of their relationship and the individual extra prone to (angrily) declare his emotions is instantly associated to his years of stagnation whereas in jail. However it’s additionally a reversal of conventional gender norms, through which ladies are often depicted as being emotional or unable to let go. It’s one other instance of how Banshee seeks to subvert viewer expectations.

But when Carrie is supposed to be Hood’s equal and accomplice in crime, Siobhan is his conscience and an opportunity to begin over. The lone feminine deputy in Banshee, she is recurrently underestimated and even focused whereas on the job. Nonetheless, Siobhan isn’t harmless or fragile, and by no means in want of saving. A survivor of home violence, she lies to Hood about the place her ex-husband is staying, and exacts revenge on him personally when he returns. This isn’t the one occasion of Siobhan bending or outright breaking the regulation all through the present. However her subtly defiant streak and quiet want for vengeance isn’t what attracts Hood to her; it’s her independence and resilience (and possibly the very fact she doesn’t instantly fall into mattress with him). Whereas it may need been constructed on a lie, their relationship is as actual and uncooked as any combat depicted within the present, including an emotional counterweight to the near-constant motion, which is why it’s so devastating when Siobhan finds out Hood lied about his id, learns his actual title, and dies throughout the span of a pair episodes in Season 3. That Siobhan is the one individual from Hood’s new life to study his id (not even viewers study it by collection finish) is proof of the depth of his love for her and the way badly he needs to begin over. Like Carrie, she holds immense energy over him, a degree pushed residence by his immense grief over not with the ability to stop her dying.

Whilst you can argue Siobhan was fridged, it’s tough to disclaim the power of the story that adopted and the emotional impact it had on Hood. The collection likes to play a recreation of “what if?” with its characters, however the lesson is all the time the identical: You possibly can’t return and alter what occurred, you may solely agree to maneuver on and attempt to be higher. So Siobhan’s dying does serve a function. Sadly, you may’t say the identical factor in regards to the dying of Rebecca Bowman (Lili Simmons), the niece of native crime boss Kai Proctor (Ulrich Thomsen) whose homicide in Season 4 units off a season-long thriller and forces Hood to confront extra of his previous selections.

A strolling set of contradictions, Rebecca is a beautiful younger lady from the native Amish neighborhood who, like Hood, is looking for her id on the outset of the present. She wields her sexuality like a weapon earlier than we ever see her decide up a blade or a gun. It’s a direct response to her modest, humble upbringing, and as she grows extra assured in herself and her place by her uncle’s facet as soon as he takes her underneath his wing within the wake of being shunned by her mother and father, she makes use of her femininity and sexuality—the one issues she will rightfully management—to her benefit in enterprise in addition to her private life. However what makes Rebecca such a powerful addition to the narrative, particularly at first, is that she’s not totally shaped. Like Deva however not like Carrie, her id continues to be being written. So for all of her bravado, the writers are cautious to remind us that she continues to be studying how Kai’s darkish and harmful world (and humanity by extension) operates. Whereas she may not have a lot outright energy, she’s brilliant, has ambition, and takes initiative, however misguided her choices might be at occasions. By giving her the room to develop and make errors, the present grants her company—even when by immersing herself in her uncle’s legal enterprises with out trying again she additionally turns into an agent of chaos, leaving nothing however dying and carnage in her wake.

It might have been shockingly straightforward for Banshee co-creators Jonathan Tropper and David Schickler to populate this hyper-violent world with stereotypical, personality-free ladies who exist solely to meet some poisonous male fantasy—the present is pulp at its most interesting, in any case—and people ladies actually do exist throughout the confines of the collection. However for a drama that all the time existed a number of levels shy of actuality, the truth that Banshee surrounds its hero with ladies who span the spectrum of womanhood—ladies who’re complicated, subvert drained tropes, and go away their mark like a handprint on the center—makes it extra life like that almost all TV collection. Ladies actually do comprise multitudes, and Banshee returns to this concept a number of occasions all through its run. So this may need been the story of the person who was not Lucas Hood, however it’s the ladies like Carrie, Deva, Siobhan, Rebecca, and even Nola who’re its legacy.

Watch on HBO Max

Kaitlin Thomas is an leisure journalist and TV critic. Her work has appeared in TV Information, Salon, and TV.com, amongst different locations. You will discover her tweets about TV, sports activities, and Walton Goggins @thekaitling or learn extra of her work at kaitlinthomas.com.

For all the most recent TV information, opinions, lists and options, observe @Paste_TV.